Out from Boneville by Jeff Smith
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
I originally read this volume years ago, when I saw that it was on a million and a half Best Comics Ever lists.
I distinctly remember that at the time, I really didn’t like it and in fact, was disappointed and surprised that it had made all of those lists! I didn’t know what a bone creature was, their stupid names turned me off, and it weirded me out that a creature called Bone was in love with a human girl. (I have a real hang-up with what I consider stupid names. Due to this, it took me years and years to finally read Tolkien even though I love high fantasy.)
Despite my own hang-up with the series, I added it to my library’s graphic novel collection, where it’s been wildly popular with 4th-6th grade boys. I recently replaced all of the raggedy copies of the series at my branch and decided to give it another chance, due to the mad love given to it by the kids.
And so, just like my experience with Tolkien, Bone’s brilliance was finally revealed to me. I’ve pretty much spent the last week (especially since I was home sick the past two days), reading vols. 1-9 + Rose.
I’m still kinda meh about Thorn and Phoney, but Fone, Bartleby, Smiley, Lucius and especially Gran’ma Ben are pretty awesome. I also really like the idea of dragons with pompom ears. They remind me of comfy slippers.
View all my reviews